I know that title seems a bit awkward but it was the best I could do.
Do you know who Oscar Pistorius is? His story is amazing and I would recommend that you read up about him.
In short the guy is a double amputee below the knees and he runs on prosthetics called ‘blades.’ He currently holds the Paralympic world records in the 100, 200, and 400 meter runs. Oscar has tried to become an Olympian in the 2008 games but the International Association of Athletics Federations (IAAF) determined that the ‘blades’ constitute “technical aids” which are not allowed in IAAF sports.
So here is the question: is it fair to allow a disabled, yet highly competent, person compete in an event where the prosthetics he uses provides him an advantage over the other competitors?
That sounds highly un-PC but the facts are there…he does not have the fatigue that other runners do…his thighs do not have to work as hard to move the prosthetics as they would to move a normal leg (pure weight differential)…the spring that is provided by the ‘blades’ allows him to be propelled forward better than any set of legs would.
This is one of those weird circumstances, where having a disability gives that person an unfair advantage over those without the disability. Oscar might still be in the Olympics though…he is looking to get on the South African team, on the relay seeing how he missed the qualifying time to make the individual team in the 400 meter.
CNN.com: 'Blade Runner' keeps Olympic hope alive
Do you know who Oscar Pistorius is? His story is amazing and I would recommend that you read up about him.
In short the guy is a double amputee below the knees and he runs on prosthetics called ‘blades.’ He currently holds the Paralympic world records in the 100, 200, and 400 meter runs. Oscar has tried to become an Olympian in the 2008 games but the International Association of Athletics Federations (IAAF) determined that the ‘blades’ constitute “technical aids” which are not allowed in IAAF sports.
So here is the question: is it fair to allow a disabled, yet highly competent, person compete in an event where the prosthetics he uses provides him an advantage over the other competitors?
That sounds highly un-PC but the facts are there…he does not have the fatigue that other runners do…his thighs do not have to work as hard to move the prosthetics as they would to move a normal leg (pure weight differential)…the spring that is provided by the ‘blades’ allows him to be propelled forward better than any set of legs would.
This is one of those weird circumstances, where having a disability gives that person an unfair advantage over those without the disability. Oscar might still be in the Olympics though…he is looking to get on the South African team, on the relay seeing how he missed the qualifying time to make the individual team in the 400 meter.
CNN.com: 'Blade Runner' keeps Olympic hope alive
Thursday, July 17, 2008
//
Labels:
Olympics
//
0
comments
//
0 comments to "Unfair or un-P.C.?"
About Me
gopfolk's shared items
Shared Science News
Blog Archive
-
▼
2008
(248)
-
▼
July
(36)
- Name that Place
- Gotta love ‘em
- I could have told you that!?!
- I read it…did you?
- Does anyone else find this funny?
- Name that Country
- "The Bush plan is a hoax,"
- Don’t be fooled…
- Name that Place
- Instinct vs. iPhone 3G
- Friday Funnies
- Democrats and Oil
- Let me be childish…
- Electoral College Question
- Unfair or un-P.C.?
- Excellent Question!!
- Name that Country
- Democrats and Gas Prices
- Name that Place
- Superhero fun…
- Digital TV Vouchers…to tax or not to tax
- Land boom
- Name that Country
- Cleaner air = global warming
- Here is the fall schedule:
- What!!?? Really?!? Plants like CO2?!?
- Name that Place
- Does this surprise anyone?
- Solar panels on you car?
- Happy Fourth of July!!
- Funnies...or maybe just comics...
- Did you vote? It may be based on genes!!??
- What is this?
- Name that Country
- There is a thought!
- Name that Place
-
▼
July
(36)
Labels
- 1st Amendment (3)
- 2008 Presidential Race (73)
- 2nd Amendment (2)
- 4th of July (1)
- 9/11 (4)
- Algore (12)
- Approval Rates (1)
- Arctic (1)
- Assembly (4)
- Astronomy (1)
- Australia (1)
- Automobile (1)
- Bailout (1)
- Bloomberg (1)
- Book (1)
- Bureaucracy (2)
- Business (3)
- Caledonia (11)
- Campaign Finance (1)
- Charlie Sykes (1)
- Chemistry (5)
- Cigarettes (1)
- Cigars (1)
- Clinton (15)
- Comics (52)
- Conceal Carry (3)
- Congress (11)
- Conspiracy (5)
- Constitution (3)
- Crime (12)
- Debates (1)
- Democrats (15)
- Doyle (12)
- DPW (1)
- Drilling (3)
- Economy (9)
- Education (11)
- Election Fraud (2)
- Elections (27)
- Electoral College (1)
- English (1)
- Environment (19)
- Ethanol (1)
- Ethics (2)
- Fantasy Congress (1)
- Federal Budget (8)
- Federal Government (2)
- Flag Day (1)
- Fox News (1)
- Gas Prices (2)
- Global Warming (62)
- Hate (3)
- Headlines (1)
- HealthCare (14)
- Hezbollah (1)
- HHS (1)
- House of Representatives (3)
- Huckster (4)
- Immigration (4)
- Impeachment (1)
- Innovation (2)
- Insurance (1)
- Interfaith Conference (1)
- Iran (1)
- Iraq (11)
- Islam (2)
- Jingle Bell Run (2)
- Journal Times (5)
- Judge Gableman (2)
- Junk Science (9)
- Katrina (1)
- Kennedy (1)
- Kenosha GOP (1)
- KRM (13)
- Language (1)
- Math (11)
- Mayor Becker (2)
- McCain (14)
- McGee (1)
- Media Bias (4)
- Medicare (1)
- Military (1)
- Minimum Wage (1)
- misc (29)
- Misc. (97)
- Money (1)
- Name that Place (45)
- NASA (2)
- NCLB (3)
- News (3)
- Nobel Prize (2)
- Number Game (1)
- Obama (20)
- Oil Companies (12)
- Olympics (2)
- Open Carry (1)
- Pelosi (1)
- PETA (1)
- Pints n Politics (3)
- Politics (7)
- Polling (3)
- Predictions (1)
- President Bush (3)
- Protest (2)
- Race (4)
- Racine (12)
- Racine County Board (4)
- Racine GOP (2)
- Rant (2)
- Religion (6)
- Republican Party (2)
- Resolutions (1)
- Rick Graber (1)
- Romney (7)
- Running (7)
- RUSD (13)
- Schools (1)
- Science (13)
- SCOTUS (2)
- Senator Lehman (1)
- Smart Growth (1)
- Solar Power (3)
- SSA (2)
- State Budget (24)
- State Convention (2)
- State Government (1)
- State of the Union (1)
- State Politics (27)
- Taxes (30)
- Technology (3)
- Television (1)
- Term Limits (1)
- Terrorism (5)
- Transportation (1)
- Travel (1)
- Trivia (122)
- UN; (2)
- Unemployment (2)
- US Senate (7)
- Veterans Day (1)
- Video (1)
- Voter ID (1)
- WEAC (1)
- Weather (2)
- WI Politician (46)